The Best Colby Cheese of 2023

Browse theprodukkt.com to find the Best Colby Cheese you're looking for, track & compare prices, and decide where to buy online or in-store.

We ranked and reviewed the top 10 Best Colby Cheese in 2023. Read more How we ranked

Emily Sloyan
  Jun 11, 2023 1:18 AM
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more

Compare Products

1
WISCONSIN CHEESE COMPANY'S | 1oz. Colby Jack Cheese | Snack Stick | 24-1oz. Individually Wrapped | Healthy Snacks
WISCONSIN CHEESE COMPANY'S | 1oz. Colby Jack Cheese | Snack Stick | 24-1oz. Individually Wrapped | Healthy Snacks
CHECK LATEST PRICE
  • SCORE
    9.7
    KT Score

    KT Score is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It from 0 to 10 are automatically scored by our advanced technological tool based upon the data collected. Our website is an independent organization and has no relation to the manufacturers, so our reviews are completely objective.

  • Brand
    WISCONSIN'S BEST and WISCONSIN CHEESE COMPANY
Features

Wisconsin Cheese Company's 1oz. Cheese Snack Sticks. These great Colby Jack Cheddar Cheese sticks are individually wrapped in a peel pack. Colby Jack Cheddar Cheese is our blended Colby and Monterey Jack plus cheddar cheeses into one stick. Bold in flavor and a great snack. Refrigeration required.

PROS
    CONS
      2
      Tillamook Medium, Sharp, Swiss & Colby Jack Sliced Cheese Sampler
      Tillamook Medium, Sharp, Swiss & Colby Jack Sliced Cheese Sampler
      CHECK LATEST PRICE
      • SCORE
        7.6
        KT Score

        KT Score is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It from 0 to 10 are automatically scored by our advanced technological tool based upon the data collected. Our website is an independent organization and has no relation to the manufacturers, so our reviews are completely objective.

      • Brand
        Tillamook
      Features
      PROS
        CONS
          3
          Cheese Popped Popcorn 45 Ounces (Bulk 5 Gal. 80 Cups)
          Cheese Popped Popcorn 45 Ounces (Bulk 5 Gal. 80 Cups)
          CHECK LATEST PRICE
          • SCORE
            8.2
            KT Score

            KT Score is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It from 0 to 10 are automatically scored by our advanced technological tool based upon the data collected. Our website is an independent organization and has no relation to the manufacturers, so our reviews are completely objective.

          • Brand
            Colby Ridge
          Features

          Popped fresh daily

          Our special recipe will have your taste buds screaming for more!

          5 gal bag/ 80 cups

          Perfect for large gatherings are a bag to snack on around the house

          Gourmet Cheese Popcorn 30 DAY SHELF LIFE

          PROS
            CONS
              4
              Tillamook Cheese 2lb Baby Loaf (Choose Flavor Below) (Colby Jack)
              Tillamook Cheese 2lb Baby Loaf (Choose Flavor Below) (Colby Jack)
              CHECK LATEST PRICE
              • SCORE
                8.1
                KT Score

                KT Score is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It from 0 to 10 are automatically scored by our advanced technological tool based upon the data collected. Our website is an independent organization and has no relation to the manufacturers, so our reviews are completely objective.

              • Brand
                Tillamook
              Features

              Pack of 1

              PROS
                CONS
                  5
                  Mesophilic Culture for Cheddar, Jack Cheese, Colby, Cottage Cheese, Monterey Jack, Quark, Sour Cream, Goat Cheese (10 doses)
                  Mesophilic Culture for Cheddar, Jack Cheese, Colby, Cottage Cheese, Monterey Jack, Quark, Sour Cream, Goat Cheese (10 doses)
                  CHECK LATEST PRICE
                  • SCORE
                    7.0
                    KT Score

                    KT Score is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It from 0 to 10 are automatically scored by our advanced technological tool based upon the data collected. Our website is an independent organization and has no relation to the manufacturers, so our reviews are completely objective.

                  • Brand
                    Bioprox
                  Features

                  cheese cultures

                  PROS
                    CONS
                      6
                      Augason Farms Freeze Dried Shredded Colby Cheese 1 lbs 14 oz No. 10 Can
                      Augason Farms Freeze Dried Shredded Colby Cheese 1 lbs 14 oz No. 10 Can
                      CHECK LATEST PRICE
                      • SCORE
                        7.8
                        KT Score

                        KT Score is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It from 0 to 10 are automatically scored by our advanced technological tool based upon the data collected. Our website is an independent organization and has no relation to the manufacturers, so our reviews are completely objective.

                      • Brand
                        Augason Farms
                      Features

                      107 Servings

                      3,210 Calories

                      Gluten-Free

                      Just add water!

                      Up to a 30 Year Shelf Life!

                      PROS
                        CONS
                          7
                          Shullsburg Creamery - Colby Cheese - 1 Pound
                          Shullsburg Creamery - Colby Cheese - 1 Pound
                          CHECK LATEST PRICE
                          • SCORE
                            8.2
                            KT Score

                            KT Score is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It from 0 to 10 are automatically scored by our advanced technological tool based upon the data collected. Our website is an independent organization and has no relation to the manufacturers, so our reviews are completely objective.

                          • Brand
                            Shullsburg Creamery
                          Features

                          Shullsburg Creamery - Colby Cheese - 1 Pound

                          Order more than one item from any of the Shullsburg Creamery product lines and save on shipping (see shipping rates and policies)

                          PROS
                            CONS
                              8
                              Wisconsin's Best and Wisconsin Cheese Company, Wisconsin Cheese & Sausage Classic Sampler (3.84 Lbs) Colby Jack, Mild Cheddar and Baby Swiss 100% Wisconsin Cheese | Birthday Gift, Gourmet Food Gift.
                              Wisconsin's Best and Wisconsin Cheese Company, Wisconsin Cheese & Sausage Classic Sampler (3.84 Lbs) Colby Jack, Mild Cheddar and Baby Swiss 100% Wisconsin Cheese | Birthday Gift, Gourmet Food Gift.
                              CHECK LATEST PRICE
                              • SCORE
                                9.4
                                KT Score

                                KT Score is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It from 0 to 10 are automatically scored by our advanced technological tool based upon the data collected. Our website is an independent organization and has no relation to the manufacturers, so our reviews are completely objective.

                              • Brand
                                WISCONSIN'S BEST and WISCONSIN CHEESE COMPANY
                              Features

                              WISCONSIN'S BEST AND WISCONSIN CHEESE COMPANY'S NATIONALLY KNOWN QUALITY CHEESE GIFTS - Classic WI Cheese and Sausage Selection, 100% Wisconsin Cheese and Summer Sausage Gift Box,

                              CHEESE AND MEAT GIFTS - Perfect Party or Snack Cheese and Sausage Combination to serve

                              CHRISTMAS CHEESE GIFTS - Online Orders for Delivery - The very best Wisconsin Cheeses and naturally smoked Sausage

                              INCLUDES; 3-Cheese Blocks-15oz. Colby Jack, 7.5 oz. Baby Swiss and 15oz. Mild Cheddar ** If a product becomes unavailable an equal product will be substituted. 2-12oz Naturally Smoked Sausage, Original Smoked, Garlic

                              GIFT IDEAS - Great Christmas Cheese Assortment and Sampler Gifts, Birthday Gifts, Gifts for Family, Friends, Gifts for Dad, Gifts for Mom, Gifts for Clients. Ships to APO's, MADE IN THE USA.

                              PROS
                                CONS
                                  9
                                  Shullsburg Creamery - Colby Cheese - 6 Pound Mini Deli Horn
                                  Shullsburg Creamery - Colby Cheese - 6 Pound Mini Deli Horn
                                  CHECK LATEST PRICE
                                  • SCORE
                                    9.0
                                    KT Score

                                    KT Score is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It from 0 to 10 are automatically scored by our advanced technological tool based upon the data collected. Our website is an independent organization and has no relation to the manufacturers, so our reviews are completely objective.

                                  • Brand
                                    Shullsburg Creamery
                                  Features

                                  Natural Colby Cheese

                                  Made the old fashion way

                                  A Wisconsin original

                                  Great for any application

                                  Order more than one item from any of the Shullsburg Creamery product lines and save on shipping (see shipping rates and policies)

                                  PROS
                                    CONS
                                      10
                                      Shullsburg Creamery - Colby Jack Cheese - 5 Pound Loaf
                                      Shullsburg Creamery - Colby Jack Cheese - 5 Pound Loaf
                                      CHECK LATEST PRICE
                                      • SCORE
                                        9.3
                                        KT Score

                                        KT Score is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It from 0 to 10 are automatically scored by our advanced technological tool based upon the data collected. Our website is an independent organization and has no relation to the manufacturers, so our reviews are completely objective.

                                      • Brand
                                        Shullsburg Creamery
                                      Features

                                      Natural Colby and Monterey Cheeses

                                      Serve sliced, diced or shredded

                                      Economical 5 pound loaf

                                      Perfect on sandwiches

                                      Order more than one item from any of the Shullsburg Creamery product lines and save on shipping (see shipping rates and policies)

                                      PROS
                                        CONS

                                          Last update on 2023-06-11 / Prices / Affiliate links / Images, and Product Highlights from Amazon Product Advertising API

                                          Editor's Notes

                                          We ranked and reviewed the top 10 Best Colby Cheese in 2023. With the support of 42,770 customer's reviews, we hope that this article can give you the most realistic view of these products. The list below contains some main brands as wisconsins-best-and-wisconsin-cheese-company, tillamook, colby-ridge, bioprox, augason-farms, shullsburg-creamery.

                                          4.5
                                          2 ratings